Posted on

The Day We Lost Our Hymnals




MAY 16, 2018

Our most popular blog series last year had to do with favorite hymns—so many of you weighed in on your personal favorites. But more and more, it appears that hymns are becoming an endangered species in Christian churches.

My wife and I have certainly noticed tifference: more and more all those hymns that have been so beloved for so many centuries are being discarded by new generations who value them not.

One of my dear friends, Esther Brummett, just relayed an article that addresses the problem. We are so impressed by it that we are featuring it this week. Not least because we are beginning to realize that the demise of hymn-singing is but the tip of the iceberg: the church services the current generation is substituting for the old is, by extension, disenfranchising all those older generations and, in essence, leaving them with no church to call their own any more.

We’ll be most interested in your reactions to the concerns voiced in the article.


By Appalachian Magazine, April 3, 2017

Few memories are as synonymous with church in my mind, as the sight of my mother holding up a raggedy old red hymnal and singing to the top of her lungs the songs of Zion.

Sadly, the number of children who are privileged to such memories in today’s world is dwindling with each passing hour; partly because church is becoming an afterthought to so many and partly because many religious establishments are “moving past” the golden era of hymnals.

The following is an article written by Tim Challies, in which he seeks to remind church folk what they lose when they give up their hymnals:

If we were to go back in time twenty or thirty years, we would find that most churches had hymnals. They had hymnals because it was the best way of providing each member of the congregation with a copy of the songs. You’d hear it in every church: “Take out your hymnal and turn to hymn 154…” And then hymnals went the way of the dodo and we began to look instead to words projected on a screen. Here is some of what we lost along the way.

We lost an established body of songs. Hymnals communicated that a church had an established collection of songs. This, in turn, communicated that its songs were vetted carefully and added to its repertoire only after careful consideration. After all, great songs are not written every day and their worth is proven only over time. Therefore, new hymns would be chosen carefully and added to new editions of the hymnal only occasionally. Churches would update their hymnals, and, therefore, their established body of songs, only once every ten or fifteen years.

We lost a deep knowledge of our songs. When we removed the hymnal, we gained the ability to add new songs to our repertoire whenever we encounter one we deem worthy. And we do—we add new songs all the time. As we add new songs with greater regularity, we sing old songs with less frequency. This reduces our familiarity with our songs so that today we have far fewer of them fixed in our minds and hearts. Few congregations could sing even the greatest hymns without that PowerPoint screen.

We lost the ability to do harmonies. Hymnody grew up at a time when instrumentation took a back seat to the voice. Hymns were most often written so they could be sung acappella or with minimal instrumentation. For that reason, hymnals almost invariably included the music for both melody and harmonies and congregations learned to sing the parts. The loss of the hymnal and the associated rise of the worship band has reduced our ability to harmonize and, in that way, to sing to the fullest of our abilities.

It often seems like all we want from the congregation is their enthusiasm. We lost the ability to sing skillfully. As congregations have lost their knowledge of their songs, they have lost the ability to sing them well. We tend to compensate for our poorly-sung songs by cranking up the volume of the musical accompaniment. The loss of the voice has given rise to the gain of the amplifier. This leads to our music being dominated by a few instrumentalists and perhaps a pair of mixed-up vocalists while the larger congregation plays only a meager role. In fact, it often seems like all we want from the congregation is their enthusiasm.

We lost the ability to have the songs in our homes. Hymnals usually lived at the church, resting from Monday to Saturday in the little pockets on the back of the pews. But people also bought their own and took them home so the family could have that established body of songs there as well. Families would often sing together as part of their family worship. It is easy to imagine a family singing “It Is Well With My Soul” after eating dinner together, but almost impossible to imagine them singing, “Oceans.”

It is probably too late to go back to the hymnal. I am not at all convinced we ought to. But it is still worth considering what we lost along the way and how congregational singing has been utterly transformed by what may appear to have been a simple and practical switch in the media. That little change from book to screen changed nearly everything.

3 thoughts on “The Day We Lost Our Hymnals

  1. The Catholic Churches I attend still have and use hymnals. Music is important. “Singing is twice praying.”

  2. The old hymns have brought comfort and courage to my heart over time. We still sing them every Sabbath in our church.

  3. I get tired listening to seven eleven music, 7 words sung 11 times! I so miss the great hyms in the hymnal. Now I feel I am forgetting the words? I know some folk enter the sanctuary when the preacher is ready to preach so they avoid the praise singing.

    Can’t beat Organ music to put one in the mood to hear the word of God.

Comments are closed.